September 19th, 2008 Chris
Pardon my tardiness with this post. I am teaching twice a week at night and it is killing me. After over a year of de-compressing from corporate life, I had gotten into a very relaxing routine that seldom required working at 10pm at night, as well as seldom wearing pants, shaving and other personal hygiene necessities whose details, dear reader, I will spare you.
I had a great question in class this week that I thought I would share with you as I think it’s a critical issue for the micro business. Basically, a student asked if it’s better in business to be a big fish in a small pond or a small fish in a big pond.
In other words, it is better to focus on a smaller, more narrow market, or a larger more general market. On the surface, it would seem that a larger pond is more attractive: more customers, more potential sales, etc…
But – especially as a micro business – that means more competitors who may be much larger than you. And as a consequence those larger competitors will be able to invest more in a product or service that has wider appeal to that target customer. And likewise, they will be able to spend more on promotion and be more able to handle aggressive pricing, etc…
The reality of the situation for you is that you may not have the resources to compete in a large, broad, general market. But don’t fret – a small pond still can be extremely lucrative.
The idea here is that if you identify a small market – something that the big fish don’t focus on, you can tune your offering to that small market. And then you can rule the pool (OK, pond – but it didn’t rhyme).
Here is an examples to make it more clear…
Let’s say I’m a small company developing a software product that helps people manage their budgets. Well, that’s a big market with lots of competitors (Intuit, Microsoft, etc…) – competitors with much more money for development, advertising, sales people, etc…
But, if I focus my product on a smaller, more narrow market – say College and University students – then I can focus on the features that those prospects care about (ex. managing tuition, student loans, etc…). And I can promote it through channels they care about – in student mags, on facebook, etc… The large competitors can’t be bothered to focus there – it’s just not lucrative enough for them.
So if you’re a student – wouldn’t you want a product that was tailored to your needs? As the business making that software, this gives you an edge and you have a shot of being the big fish in that small pond.
Oh, kind reader, but you say that this limits your growth. Well, yes it does. But it doesn’t stop you from venturing out into multiple small markets, one at a time. The “bowling pin” strategy (from the classic book Crossing the Chasm) involves winning one small market, then taking on another small market, etc… Success in the first narrow market funds your foray into the second.
Now, often people clang with this, assuming it means that any customer not from your target market is essentially a leper and must be avoided at all costs. Of course this is not the case – embrace anyone’s wallet but reserve much of your investments only for your target.
Another issue is that typically, a micro business hasn’t started with this focus and it’s simply not practical to shift the whole business at once. Do you really abondon a general marketing approach that’s bringing in revenue and start from scratch targeting a new one? Short answer, nope. You transition.
Our business started as a generic sales training business and we continue to serve customers across a variety of target markets. A couple of years ago, we identified an opportunity in a particular narrow market (specific to one industry) and extended our efforts to target it. So, for example, we have a bi-weekly newsletter that goes out to our base and we also recently launched a version of it specialized for this narrow target market.
This “extension” plan takes longer as resources are spread thinner, but it’s really the only practical thing you can do where you start with a more generic base.
Having trouble identifying a target smaller market on which to focus. Try this exercise: print out a list of your customers from last year and try to spot something common trends: is there a large number from a particular industry, company size, age demographic, geographical region, income level, etc… These are the first clues to where you’ve already got an edge… And if it’s already not full of competitors also focusing on those targets – it may be the right small pond for you.
C.
Posted in Marketing | No Comments »