What I Really, Really Want
August 26th, 2008 Chris
While on vacation, we typically stock up with reading and other materials to amuse ourselves. Colleen typically brings a couple of good books and a variety of trashy magazines (Hello!, People, etc…). I am not so ambitious, bringing my favourite magazine, the Economist, and the first two seasons of The Wire.
Of course, I am always tempted by the trashy magazines that Colleen brings. I know it’s very low brow but I just love the salacious gossip. I have even been known to watch TMZ.
It was in one of those magazines that I saw a former spice girl, Gerry Halliwell. I’m not sure which one she was (snoozey, dopey, sleazy, …?) but she was showing off her new fit-’n-healthy body adorned in a particularly small bathing suit. I immediately put the magazine down – shameless use of sex to sell, and all… Well, almost immediately.
I was never a big fan of the Spice Gals and was even hard pressed to remember any of their songs. Although I do remember a chorus from one of their videos, “I’ll tell you what I really want, what I really, really want”. ‘Fraid that’s all I can remember…
Just a few short hours after this reminder of all things wrong in popular music, that verse came storming back into my head. Believe it or not, it wasn’t when I was going through another copy of People, Us, or whatever. It was when I logged into our Infusion application.
As a quick refresher, Infusion is the software we use that runs all our marketing, contact management, order management, etc… It’s an extremely effective piece of kit for our business as it does many things very well (not great, but very well) in a single package.
While larger businesses would be paying gobs of money for Siebel or SalesForce.com and be stitching together different systems, Infusion does almost everything we need it to do.
My biggest complaint with the system is that it has been quite buggy and unstable (ad passim ad nauseum). I can live without a particular feature here and there, but I cannot live with unpredictable behavior and stuff just not working the way it is supposed to.
The reason why I reacted the way I did when I went to Infusion this morning was that they had completely redesigned the user interface of the software. It looked completely different and many of the functions had been renamed. This is not what I really, really wanted.
The new application does look much better and is indeed easier to use. And the new menus and terminology are much more intuitive. My issue is that it will have been a very substantial investment to re-do the front end while adding virtually no benefit to me as an end user.
I’ve gone through this battle in my previous life. I remember one product that didn’t have the most visually appealing user interface. So the sales team said this was a major issue and we were losing deals because of it. I didn’t buy it – when selling to businesses, there are a host of other factors that are more critical to the customer. But when the direct sales force complains, beatings ensue and the changes were made – along with the commitment from the sales team that more deals would result.
And what happened? Absolutely nothing – no new deals. Why? Look and feel wasn’t a particularly critical feature for the customer. Sure, some would say it’s not pretty – even ugly – then they’d buy the product for the value it would bring their business.
Picking which features make it and which don’t is one of the tough jobs of any product manager. There are a combination of factors that must be considered but, at the end of the day, you are trying to create greater perceived value in the eyes of the customer relative to your competitors. That way you win and keep more customers and make more money.
Back to Infusion… They’re in a very enviable position in that they don’t have any direct competitors. And while clunky, the previous interface got the job done. So why invest in a brand new interface? I can speculate a number of pressures:
- sales complaining that the product is hard to use and, thus, hard to sell
- support complaining about too many help desk calls because the product is hard to use
- development complaining that the app should be using AJAX
Not that these aren’t legitimate concerns. But I bet if you polled the customer base, asking them to prioritize stability, quality, a host of features that aren’t there yet and the ease of use of the interface, the interface would come last.
And redoing the front end of the app is risky stuff – lots can go wrong. Especially with a team that doesn’t have the greatest track record in bug-free code.
So I didn’t get what I really, really want: a stable, high quality product. Instead I got a slick new interface.
I logged four bugs in the first fifteen minutes. Sigh.
C.
Posted in Technology | No Comments »
I was out for a beer with a friend the other day (surely not again) and I mentioned my upcoming vacation to P.E.I. I was recounting how it’s always a bit of a challenge finding a place that works for us. We have very specific requirements: must take a dog, must be near the water, must have a dishwasher (I gave up “roughing it” years ago), and must have high speed Internet.
I’m very glad we’re on vacation this week. Although vacation is always a bit relative with us. Like most with a micro business, there never really is 100% down time as you’re in critical path for so many activities. But that does mean that I get to drink a beer in the afternoon while being mildly productive.
I was out for dinner and drinks with a few friends last night (surely not again). We went to our regular sushi place and then to the pub for a few pints. These are guys that I used to work with so we get to share our war stories of working in a mid/large company and all the insanity that ensues. I do suspect our company had more than its fair share with the prevailing hypothesis that there was way too much lead in the water in Dallas. What company you ask? I’m afraid that discretion demands that its identity stay private although evENTUally I may reveal it…
I’m not sure what you’re like, but we are notorious for taking pictures on vacation, uploading them onto the computer, and never looking at them again. We rarely even go through and purge all the extra shots we take to make sure one is perfect (’cause with digital they’re free!).
Last night, I was out with a couple of friends for a couple of beers (kindest reader, it would be polite to now express some modicum of surprise). As it turns out, two thirds of the people around the table have a blog. One was mine and the other belongs to 
Every few months, a few buddies and I head off to a city for a couple days of good food, drink and (no comments please) shopping. This time, we were off to Montreal – just a couple of hours down the road. If you’ve never been – it’s a fantastic city with some of the best food and most fun nightlife in North America.